<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<?xml-model href="../../../Schema,%20CSS%20and%20Template%20Files/YB_schema2.rnc" type="application/relax-ng-compact-syntax"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
   <teiHeader>
      <fileDesc>
         <titleStmt>
            <title>Yellow Nineties 2.0</title>
            <title type="YBV3_greenwood_women"/>
            <title>The Yellow Book: An Illustrated Quarterly, Volume 3 October 1894</title>
            <editor>Lorraine Janzen Kooistra</editor>
         </titleStmt>
         <editionStmt>
            <p>
               <date>2019</date>
            </p>
         </editionStmt>
         <publicationStmt>
            <idno>YBV3_5pr</idno>
            <publisher>Yellow Nineties 2.0</publisher>
            <pubPlace>Ryerson University Centre for Digital H</pubPlace>
            <address>
               <addrLine>English Department</addrLine>
               <addrLine>350 Victoria Street,</addrLine>
               <addrLine>Toronto ON,</addrLine>
               <addrLine>M5B 2K3</addrLine>
               <addrLine>Canada</addrLine>
            </address>
            <availability>
               <p>Usable according to the Creative Commons License <ref
                     target="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/">Attribution
                     Non-commercial Share-alike</ref>.</p>
            </availability>
         </publicationStmt>
         <sourceDesc>
            <biblStruct>
               <monogr>
                  <editor>
                     <persName>Henry Harland &amp; Aubrey Beardsley</persName>
                  </editor>
                  <author>Frederick Greenwood</author>
                  <title>Women—Wives or Mothers</title>
                  <imprint>
                     <publisher>John Lane</publisher>
                     <pubPlace> London </pubPlace>
                     <publisher>Copeland &amp; Day</publisher>
                     <pubPlace>Boston</pubPlace>
                     <date>October 1894</date>
                     <biblScope>Greenwood, Frederick. "Women—Wives or Mothers." <emph rend="italic"
                           >The Yellow Book</emph>, vol. 3, October 1894, pp. 11-18. <emph rend="italic">
                           Yellow Book Digital Edition</emph>, edited by Dennis Denisoff and Lorraine Janzen
                        Kooistra, 2010-2014. <emph rend="italic">Yellow Nineties 2.0</emph>,
                     	Ryerson University Centre for Digital Humanities, 2019.
                        https://1890s.ca/YBV3_greenwood_women/</biblScope>
                  </imprint>
               </monogr>
            </biblStruct>
         </sourceDesc>
      </fileDesc>
      <encodingDesc>
         <editorialDecl>
            <p>Our editorial method is informed by social-text editing principles. By “text” we mean
               verbal and visual printed material, including non-referential physical elements such as
               bindings, page layouts, and ornaments. We view any text as the outcome of collaborative
               processes that have specific manifestations at precise historical moments.
               The Yellow Nineties Online publishes facsimile editions of a select collection of fin-de-
               siècle aesthetic periodicals, together with paratexts of production and reception such as
               cover designs, advertising materials, and reviews. This historical material is enhanced
               by two kinds of peer-reviewed scholarly commentary: biographies of the periodicals’
               contributors and associates; and critical introductions to each title and volume by
               experts in the field. All scholarly material on the site is vetted by the editor(s) and peer-
               reviewed by them and/or an international board of advisors. The site as a whole is peer-
               reviewed by NINES (Networked Infrastructure for Nineteenth-Century Electronic
               Scholarship). Contributors to the site retain personal copyright in their material. The
               site is licensed with a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0
               license. Both primary and secondary materials, including all visual images, are marked
               up in TEI- (Textual-Encoding Initiative) compliant XML (Extensible Markup
               Language). To ensure maximum flexibility for users, magazines are available on the site
               as virtual objects (facsimiles) in FlipBook form; in HTML for online reading; in PDF for
               downloading and collecting; and in XML for those who wish to review and/or adapt our
               tag sets. In order to make ornamental devices, such as initial letters, head- and tail-
               pieces, searchable, we have developed a Database of Ornament in OMEKA, and linked it
               to the relevant pages of each magazine edition. As a dynamic structure, a scholarly
               website is always in process; Phase One of The Yellow Nineties Online (2010-2015) is
               completed and Phase Two (2016-2021) is underway.</p>
         </editorialDecl>
      </encodingDesc>
      <profileDesc>
         <creation>
            <date>1894</date>
         </creation>
         <langUsage>
            <language ident="en">English</language>
            <language ident="la">Latin</language>
            <language ident="de">German</language>
         </langUsage>
         <textClass>
            <keywords scheme="#lcsh">
               <list>
                  <item>English literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals</item>
                  <item>Great Britain -- Periodicals</item>
               </list>
            </keywords>
            <keywords scheme="ninesGenre">
               <list>
                  <item>Nonfiction</item>
                  <note>Possible Genres (multiple): "Fiction," "Nonfiction," "Poetry," "Paratext" (TOC, prospecti, advertisements, frontmatter, titlepage), "Review" (older reviews),
                     "Criticism" (including critical introductions), "Visual Art" (images, bio images), Historiography (bios),"Bibliography"
                     (intros, crit, bios, anything with a bibliography attached), "Drama," "Ephemera," "Translation," "Religion," 
                     "Travel Writing," "Music, Other,")
                     <!--Add items as necessary. Remove items not used.-->
                  </note>
               </list>
            </keywords>
            
            <keywords scheme="ninesType">
               <list>
                  <item>Periodical</item>
                  <note>Possible Types (singular): "Periodical" (texts/most stuff), "Interactive Resource" (current writing, 
                     biographies, not old reviews), "Still Image" (images, visual art), "Physical Object" (posters,
                     prospecti)</note>
                  <!-- only choose one item-->
               </list>
            </keywords>
            
            <keywords scheme="ninesDiscipline">
               <list>
                  <item>Book History</item>
                  <item>Literature</item>
                  <note>Possible Disciplines (multiple): "Book History (include for all periodical items)," "Literature," "Art History (use for art, also use for reviews)," "History (don't use in a general sense)," "Theatre Studies,"
                     "Musicology," "Philosophy," "Anthropology," "Science"</note>
                  <!--Add items as necessary. Remove items not used.-->
               </list>
            </keywords>
         </textClass>
      </profileDesc>
   </teiHeader>
   <text>
      <body>
         <div n="YBV3_5pr" type="prose">
            <head>
               <title level="a">Women—Wives or Mothers</title>
            </head>
            <byline>By<docAuthor>
                  <ref target="#FGR"> A Woman</ref>
               </docAuthor>
            </byline>
            <p>WE believe it to be well within the truth to say that most<lb/> men cherish, hidden
               away in an inner pocket of conscious-<lb/>ness, their own particular ideal of the
               perfect woman. Sole<lb/> sovereign she of that unseen kingdom, and crowned and
               sceptred<lb/> she remains long after her faithful subject has put aside the
               other<lb/> playthings of his youth. The fetish is from time to time regarded<lb/>
               rapturously, though sorrowfully, by its possessor, but it is never<lb/> brought forth
               for public exhibition. If to worship and adore<lb/> were the beginning and end of the
               pastime, no cavilling word<lb/> need be said, for the power to worship is a great and
               good gift,<lb/> and, save in the fabulous region of politics, is nowadays so rare
               an<lb/> one, that when discovered in the actual world its steady encour-<lb/> agement
               becomes a duty. But to this apparently innocent diver-<lb/> sion there is another
               side. Somewhat grave consequences are apt<lb/> to follow, and it is to this point of
               view that we wish to call<lb/> attention.</p>
            <p>When the woman uncreate becomes the measuring rod by which<lb/> her unconscious
               living rivals are judged, and are mostly found<lb/> wanting, then we are minded to
               lift up our voice and put in<lb/> a plea for fair-play. To the shrined deity are
               given by the acolo-<lb/> thyst, not only all the perfections of person demanded by a
               severely<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">aesthetic</fw>
            <pb n="20"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">
               <fw type="pageNum">12</fw> Women—Wives or Mothers</fw>
            <p>aesthetic sense, but all the moral qualities as well. Every grace of<lb/> every fair
               woman he has ever met—the best attributes of his<lb/> mother, his sister, and his
               aunt—are freely hers. None of the<lb/> slight blemishes which occasionally tarnish
               the high lustre of<lb/> virtue, none of the caprices to which sirens are
               constitutionally<lb/> liable, are permitted. Faultless wife and faultless mother must
               she<lb/> be, faithful lover and long-suffering friend, or he will have none<lb/> of
               her in his temple. Now, this is surely a wholly unreasonable,<lb/> an utterly
               extravagant demand on the part of man, and if analysed<lb/> carefully, will, we
               believe, be found to yield egoism and gluttony<lb/> in about equal parts. How, we
               venture to inquire, would he meet<lb/> a like claim, were it in turn presented to him
               ? A witty and light-<lb/> hearted lady—a remnant yet remains, in spite of the advent
               of the<lb/> leaping, bounding, new womanhood—once startled a selected<lb/> audience
               by the general statement, "All men are widowers."<lb/> But even if this generous
               utterance can be accepted as absolutely<lb/> accurate, it can hardly be taken as a
               proof of man's fitness for<lb/> both the important roles involved.</p>
            <p>For our own part, we are convinced that, broadly speaking,<lb/> the exception only
               proving the rule—whatever that supporting<lb/> phrase may mean—woman, fresh from
               Nature's moulding, is, so far<lb/> as first intention is concerned, a predestined
               wife <emph rend="italic">or</emph> mother. She<lb/> is not both, though doubtless by
               constant endeavour, art and duty<lb/> taking it turn and turn about, the dual end
               may, with hardness, be<lb/> attained unto. For Nature is not economic. Far from her
               is<lb/> the fatal utilitarian spirit which too often prompts the improver<lb/> man
               (or—dare we confess it ?—still more frequently woman) to<lb/> attempt to make one
               object do the work of two. From all such<lb/> sorry makeshifts Nature, the great
               modeller in clay, turns contemp-<lb/> tuously away. Not long ago we read in a lady's
               journal of a<lb/> 'combination gown' which by some cunning arrangement, the<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">secret</fw>
            <pb n="21"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">By a Woman <fw type="pageNum">13</fw>
            </fw>
            <p>secret whereof was only known to its lucky possessor, would do<lb/> alternate day and
               night duty with equal credit and despatch. We<lb/> have no desire to disparage the
               varied merits of this ingenious con-<lb/> trivance, but at the best it must remain an
               unlovely hybrid thing.<lb/> Probably it knew this well, for gowns, too, have their
               feelings, and<lb/> before now have been seen to go limp in a twinkling, overcome<lb/>
               by a sudden access of despondency. Such a moment must certainly<lb/> have come to the
               omnibus garment referred to above, when it<lb/> found itself breakfasting with a
               severe and one-idea'd "tailor-made,"<lb/> or, more cruel experience still, dining
               skirt by skirt with a<lb/> "mysterious miracle"—the latest label—in gossamer and
               satin.</p>
            <p>We dare to go even further, and to declare that every woman<lb/> knows in her
               heart—though never, never will she admit it to you—<lb/> within which fold she was
               intended to pass. Is it an exaggeration<lb/> to say that many a girl marries out of
               the superabundance of the<lb/> maternal instinct, though she may the while be
               absolutely ignorant<lb/> of the motive power at work ? Believing herself to be
               wildly<lb/> enamoured of the man of her (or her parents') choice, she is in<lb/>
               reality only in love with the nursery of an after-day. Of worship<lb/> between
               husband and wife, as a factor in the transaction, she<lb/> knows nothing, or likely
               enough she imagines it present when it<lb/> is the sweet passion of pity, or the more
               subtle patronage of<lb/> bestowal, one or both, which are urging her forward into
               marriage.<lb/> Gratitude, none the less real because unrealised, towards the man<lb/>
               who thus enables her to fulfil her true destiny—the saving of souls<lb/> alive—has
               also its share in the complex energy. Well for the<lb/> husband of this wife if he
               allows himself gradually to occupy the<lb/> position of eldest and most important of
               her children, to whom<lb/> indeed a somewhat larger liberty is accorded, but from
               whom also<lb/> more is required. In return for this submission boundless will be<lb/>
               the care and devotion bestowed upon his upbringing day by day.<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">He</fw>
            <pb n="22"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">
               <fw type="pageNum">14</fw> Women—Wives or Mothers</fw>
            <p>He will be foolish if he utters aloud, or even says in the silence of<lb/> his heart,
               that motherhood is good, but that wifehood was what he<lb/> wanted. It would be but a
               bootless kicking against the pricks.<lb/> For he has chosen the mother-woman, and it
               is beyond his<lb/> power, or that of any other specialist, to effect the
               fundamental<lb/> change for which his soul may long. It only remains for him to<lb/>
               make the best of a very good bargain, and one to which it is very<lb/> probable his
               strict personal merits may hardly have entitled him.</p>
            <p>If such a marriage is childless, it may still be a very useful one.<lb/> Nature's
               accommodations often verge on the miraculous. The<lb/> unemployed maternal instincts
               of the wife easily work themselves<lb/> out in an unlimited and universal auntdom. It
               must be confessed<lb/> that bad blunders are apt to ensue, but where the intentions
               are<lb/> good, the pavement should not be too closely scanned. In fiction<lb/> these
               are the Dinahs, the Romolas, the Dorotheas, the Mary<lb/> Garths. Dear to the soul of
               the female writer is the maternal<lb/> type. With loving, if tiresome frequency, she
               is presented to us<lb/> again and yet again. In truth we sometimes grow a little
               weary<lb/> of her saintly monotony. But as it is given to few of us to have<lb/> the
               courage of our tastes, we bear with her, as we bear with other<lb/> not altogether
               pleasing appliances, presented to us by earnest<lb/> friends, with the assurance that
               they are for our good, or for our<lb/> education, or some other equally superfluous
               purpose.</p>
            <p>With the male artist this female model is not nearly so popular.<lb/> It may be that
               he feels himself wholly unequal to cope with her<lb/> countless perfections. Certain
               it is that he makes but a sad<lb/> muddle of it when he tries. Witness Thackeray's
               faded, bloodless<lb/> Lady Esmond, as set against his glowing wayward Trix—she,<lb/>
               by the way, a beautifully-marked specimen of the wife-woman—<lb/> though whether it
               would be pure wisdom to take her to wife<lb/> must be left an open question. Still,
               we have in our time loved<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">her</fw>
            <pb n="23"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">By a Woman <fw type="pageNum">15</fw>
            </fw>
            <p>her well, and some of us have found it hard to forgive the black<lb/> treachery done
               in bringing her back in her old age, a painted<lb/> and scolding harridan. For these,
               well-loved of the gods, should, in<lb/> fiction at least, die young.</p>
            <p> Truth compels us to own regretfully that man in his self-indul-<lb/> gence shrinks
               from both the giving and receiving of dull moments,<lb/> whilst woman, believing
               devoutly in their saving grace, is altruistic<lb/> enough to devote herself with
               enthusiasm to the task of their ad-<lb/> ministration. Now, dull moments are apt to
               lie hidden about the<lb/> creases of the severely classic robe, which, in the
               story-books at<lb/> any rate, these heroines always wear. We must all agree that<lb/>
               during the last twenty years this type, with its portentous accumu-<lb/> lation of
               self-conscious responsibility has increased alarmingly.<lb/> To what is the increase
               to be attributed ? The too rapid growth<lb/> of the female population stands out
               plainly as prime cause. Legis-<lb/> lators are athirst for things practical. Is it
               beyond their power to<lb/> devise some method of dealing with this problem ? The
               Chinese<lb/> plan is painfully obvious, but only as a last and despairful
               resource,<lb/> when the wise men of Westminster sitting on committees and<lb/>
               commissions have failed, can it be mentioned for adoption in<lb/> Europe. We are,
               alas ! Science-ridden, and are likely to remain<lb/> thus bridled and saddled for
               weary years to come. Every bush<lb/> and every bug grows its own specialist, and yet
               we, the patient,<lb/> the long-suffering public, are left to endure both the fogs
               that<lb/> make of London one murky pit, and the redundant female birth-<lb/> rate
               which threatens more revolutions than all the forces of the<lb/> Anarchists in active
               combination. Meanwhile these devotees of<lb/> the abstract play about with all sorts
               of trifles, masquerading as<lb/> grave thinkers, hoping thus to escape their certain
               judgment-day.<lb/> The identification of criminals by the variation of
               thumb-prints<lb/> is a pretty conceit ; so too is the record of the influence of
               the<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">moon</fw>
            <pb n="24"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">
               <fw type="pageNum">16</fw> Women—Wives or Mothers</fw>
            <p>moon on the tides, which, we are informed, employs all to itself a<lb/> whole and
               highly paid professor with a yearly average of three<lb/> pupils at Cambridge. But
               what are these save mere fads, on a par<lb/> with leapfrog and skittles, in the
               presence of the momentous<lb/> problems about and around us ? Let these gentlemen
               jockeys look<lb/> to it. The hour is not far distant when public opinion shall<lb/>
               discover their uselessness and send them about their business.</p>
            <p>In humbler ways, too, much might be done to stem the morbid<lb/> activity of the
               collective female conscience. Big sins lie at the<lb/> doors of the hosts of good men
               and women who turn out year by<lb/> year tons of "books for the young" to serve as
               nutriment for the<lb/> hungry nestlings of culpable, thoughtless parents. It is hard
               to<lb/> overstate the pernicious effect of this class of <emph rend="italic"
                  >motif</emph> literature.<lb/>
               <emph rend="italic">Féerie</emph> in old or new dress is the only nourishing food for
               the<lb/> happy child who is to remain happy. The little girl, aged seven,<lb/> who
               lately wrote in her diary before going to bed, "Of what <emph rend="italic"
                  >real</emph>
               <lb/> use am I in the world ?" had, it is certain, been denied her<lb/> Andersen, her
               Grimm, her Carroll, even her Blue fairy book.<lb/> Turned in to browse on "
               Ministering Children," "Agatha's First<lb/> Prayer," and the fatal "Eric"—into how
               many editions has this<lb/> last well-meaning but poisonous romance not passed—the
               little<lb/> victim of parental stupidity is thus left with an organ damaged for<lb/>
               life by over-much stimulation at the start. This new massacre of<lb/> the innocents
               is of purely nineteenth-century growth. It dates<lb/> from the era of the awakened
               conscience, and is coincident<lb/> with the formation of all the societies for the
               regeneration of the<lb/> human race.</p>
            <p>
               <emph rend="italic">Per contra</emph>, the wife-woman, though but seldom to be
               met<lb/> with in the multitudinous pages written by women, is the well-<lb/> beloved,
               the chosen of the male artist. Week-days and Sundays<lb/> he paints her portrait.
               Shakespeare returns to her again and again,<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">as</fw>
            <pb n="25"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">By a Woman <fw type="pageNum">17</fw>
            </fw>
            <p>as though it were hard to part from her. Wicked Trix stands out<lb/> as bold leader
               of one bad band. Tess belongs to the family, though<lb/> she is of another branch ;
               so does Cathy of Wuthering Heights,<lb/> and Lyndall of the African Farm ; whilst
               latest and slightest scamp<lb/> of the lot comes dancing Dodo of Lambeth. Save in a
               strictly<lb/> specialised sense, none of this class can be said to contrive the<lb/>
               greatest good of the greatest number. These are the women to<lb/> whom the nursery is
               at best but an interlude, and at worst a real<lb/> interruption of their life's
               strongest interests. They are not<lb/> skilled in dealing with early teething
               troubles, nor in the rival<lb/> merits of Welsh and Saxony flannel stuffs. Their
               crass ignorance<lb/> of all this deep lore may, it is true, go far to kill off
               superfluous<lb/> offspring, but, unjust as it would appear, these are the
               mothers<lb/> who each succeeding year become more and more adored of their<lb/> sons.
               Fribblers though they be, they sweeten the world's corners<lb/> with the perfume of
               their charm. And the bit of world's work in<lb/> which they excel is the keeping
               alive the tradition of woman's<lb/> witchery. Who, then, can deny them their plain
               uses ? When<lb/> Fate is kind and bestows the fitting partner, the fires of their
               love<lb/> never die down. They remain lovers to the end. Their husbands<lb/> need
               fear no rival, not even in the person of their own superior<lb/> son. When Fate is
               unkind and things go crookedly, these are the<lb/> women whose wreckage strews life's
               high road, and from whom<lb/> their wiser sisters turn reprovingly away. For the good
               woman<lb/> who has to "work for her living," and who pretends to enjoy the<lb/>
               healthful after-pains in her moral system, is rarely tolerant of the<lb/> existence
               of the <emph rend="italic">leichtsinriige</emph> sister for whom, as to Elijah at
               the<lb/> brook, dainty morsels without labour are cheerfully provided by<lb/> that
               inconsequent raven, man. This lady goes gaily, wearing<lb/> what she has not spun,
               reaping where she has not sown. Sad<lb/> reflections these for the high-souled woman
               whose enlightened<lb/>
            </p>
            <fw type="catchword">demand</fw>
            <pb n="26"/>
            <fw type="runningHead">
               <fw type="pageNum">18</fw> Women—Wives or Mothers</fw>
            <p>demand for justice turns in its present day impotency to wrath and<lb/>
               bitterness.</p>
            <p>Wisdom and foresight are never the "attributes of the wife-<lb/> woman. Charm,
               beguilement, fascination of sorts, form her poor<lb/> equipment for life's selective
               struggle. These gifts cannot be said<lb/> to promise, save when the stars are in
               happiest conjunction, long<lb/> life and useful days for her intimates. Variations of
               the two types<lb/> of Primitive Woman may abound, but the broad distinction<lb/>
               between them is clearly cut and readily to be made out by<lb/> the dullest groper
               after truth. We can imagine a modern Daniel<lb/> addressing (quite uselessly) a modem
               disciple thus :</p>
            <p>"Look to it now, O young man ! that your feet go straight, and<lb/> slip not in
               search for the pearl that may be hid away for you.<lb/> For she who loveth you best
               may work you all evil, and she who<lb/> loveth her own soul's travail best will
               hardly fail you in the days<lb/> and the years. But Love remaineth, and the way of
               return<lb/> is not."</p>
         </div>
      </body>
   </text>
</TEI>
