<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!-- headRight (+2 sp, total w trans.scenario = 12 sp) pageNumRight (+12 sp, total w trans.scenario = 22 sp) -->
<?xml-model href="../../../../../LabShares/CDHshare/1890s.ca/Schema,%20CSS%20and%20Template%20Files/YB_schema2.rnc" type="application/relax-ng-compact-syntax"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
   <teiHeader>
      <fileDesc>
         <titleStmt>
            <title>Yellow Nineties 2.0</title>
            <title>The Pagan Review</title>
            <title type="TPR_brooks_contemporaryrecord"/>
            <editor>Dennis Denisoff</editor>
            <editor>Lorraine Janzen Kooistra</editor>

         </titleStmt>
         <editionStmt>
            <edition>
               <date>2021</date>
            </edition>
         </editionStmt>
         <publicationStmt>
            <idno>TPR_12pr</idno>
            <publisher>Yellow Nineties 2.0</publisher>
            <pubPlace>Ryerson University Centre for Digital Humanities</pubPlace>
            <address>
               <addrLine>English Department</addrLine>
               <addrLine>350 Victoria Street,</addrLine>
               <addrLine>Toronto ON,</addrLine>
               <addrLine>M5B 2K3</addrLine>
               <addrLine>Canada</addrLine>
            </address>
            <availability>
               <p>Usable according to the Creative Commons License <ref
                     target="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/">Attribution
                     Non-commercial Share-alike</ref>.</p>
            </availability>
         </publicationStmt>
         <sourceDesc>
            <biblStruct>
               <monogr>
                  <editor>William Sharp</editor>
                  <author>W.H. Brooks</author>
                  <title>Contemporary Record</title>
                  <imprint>
                     <publisher>W.H. Brooks</publisher>
                     <pubPlace>Sussex</pubPlace>
                     <date>August 1892</date>
                     <biblScope>Brooks, W.H. [William Sharp]. "Contemporary Record." <emph
                           rend="italics">The Pagan Review,</emph> vol. 1, August 1892, pp. 59-62.
                           <emph rend="italic">The Pagan Review Digital Edition</emph>, edited by
                        Dennis Denisoff and Lorraine Janzen Kooistra, 2010. <emph rend="italics"
                           >Yellow Nineties 2.0,</emph> Ryerson University Centre for Digital
                        Humanities, 2021. https://1890s.ca/tpr-brooks-contemporary/ </biblScope>
                  </imprint>
               </monogr>
            </biblStruct>
         </sourceDesc>
      </fileDesc>
      <encodingDesc>
         <editorialDecl>
            <p>Our editorial method is informed by social-text editing principles. By “text” we mean
               verbal and visual printed material, including non-referential physical elements such
               as bindings, page layouts, and ornaments. We view any text as the outcome of
               collaborative processes that have specific manifestations at precise historical
               moments. The Yellow Nineties Online publishes facsimile editions of a select
               collection of fin-de- siècle aesthetic periodicals, together with paratexts of
               production and reception such as cover designs, advertising materials, and reviews.
               This historical material is enhanced by two kinds of peer-reviewed scholarly
               commentary: biographies of the periodicals’ contributors and associates; and critical
               introductions to each title and volume by experts in the field. All scholarly
               material on the site is vetted by the editor(s) and peer- reviewed by them and/or an
               international board of advisors. The site as a whole is peer- reviewed by NINES
               (Networked Infrastructure for Nineteenth-Century Electronic Scholarship).
               Contributors to the site retain personal copyright in their material. The site is
               licensed with a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 license.
               Both primary and secondary materials, including all visual images, are marked up in
               TEI- (Textual-Encoding Initiative) compliant XML (Extensible Markup Language). To
               ensure maximum flexibility for users, magazines are available on the site as virtual
               objects (facsimiles) in FlipBook form; in HTML for online reading; in PDF for
               downloading and collecting; and in XML for those who wish to review and/or adapt our
               tag sets. In order to make ornamental devices, such as initial letters, head- and
               tail- pieces, searchable, we have developed a Database of Ornament in OMEKA, and
               linked it to the relevant pages of each magazine edition. As a dynamic structure, a
               scholarly website is always in process; Phase One of The Yellow Nineties Online
               (2010-2015) is completed and Phase Two (2016-2021) is underway.</p>
         </editorialDecl>
      </encodingDesc>
      <profileDesc>
         <creation>
            <date>1892</date>
         </creation>
         <langUsage>
            <language ident="en">English</language>
         </langUsage>
         <textClass>
            <keywords scheme="#lcsh">
               <list>
                  <item>English literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals</item>
                  <item>Great Britain -- Periodicals</item>
               </list>
            </keywords>
            <keywords scheme="ninesGenre">
               <list>
                  <item>Paratext</item>
                  <note>Possible Genres (multiple): "Fiction," "Nonfiction," "Poetry," "Paratext"
                     (TOC, prospecti, advertisements, frontmatter, titlepage), "Review" (older
                     reviews), "Criticism" (including critical introductions), "Visual Art" (images,
                     bio images), Historiography (bios),"Bibliography" (intros, crit, bios, anything
                     with a bibliography attached), "Drama," "Ephemera," "Translation," "Religion,"
                     "Travel Writing," "Music, Other,")
                     <!--Add items as necessary. Remove items not used.-->
                  </note>
               </list>
            </keywords>

            <keywords scheme="ninesType">
               <list>
                  <item>Periodical</item>
                  <note>Possible Types (singular): "Periodical" (texts/most stuff), "Interactive
                     Resource" (current writing, biographies, not old reviews), "Still Image"
                     (images, visual art), "Physical Object" (posters, prospecti)</note>
                  <!-- only choose one item-->
               </list>
            </keywords>

            <keywords scheme="ninesDiscipline">
               <list>
                  <item>Book History</item>
                  <item>Literature</item>
                  <note>Possible Disciplines (multiple): "Book History (include for all periodical
                     items)," "Literature," "Art History (use for art, also use for reviews),"
                     "History (don't use in a general sense)," "Theatre Studies," "Musicology,"
                     "Philosophy," "Anthropology," "Science"</note>
                  <!--Add items as necessary. Remove items not used.-->
               </list>
            </keywords>
         </textClass>
      </profileDesc>
   </teiHeader>
   <text>
      <body>
         <div n="TPR_12pr" type="paratext">

            <!--HEADER-->
            <pb n="62"/>

            <fw type="runningHead">
               <fw type="headLeft">CONTEMPORARY RECORD</fw>
               <fw type="pageNumRight">&#160;&#160; 59</fw>
            </fw>
            <!--HEADER-->

            <head>
               <title level="a">CONTEMPORARY RECORD. </title>
            </head>

            <p>
               <emph rend="indent5a">ME JUDICE.</emph>
            </p>

            <div type="prose">
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>The publishing season of 1892 is memorable for the<lb/>
                  commercial success of a biographical and philosophical <lb/>book, <emph
                     rend="italic">The History of David Grieve</emph>: for the reluctantly
                  <lb/>allowed literary and library success of a great work <lb/>of fiction, <emph
                     rend="italic">Tess of the D' Urbervilles</emph>: and for the disastrous<lb/>
                  failure of the latest production of a great poet, <emph rend="italic">The
                     <lb/>Sisters</emph>. Of these, Mrs. Humphry Ward's novel is<lb/> indeed, as has
                  been claimed, monumental. In this <lb/>country monuments are erected to the memory
                  of the <lb/>departed only. The powerful and beautiful and emi-<lb/>nently
                  significant romance by Mr. Thomas Hardy has one<lb/> drawback—for the mentally and
                  spiritually anaemic:<lb/> it is sane, vigorous, full-blooded, robust, with the
                  pulse<lb/>of indomitable youth. It is a book to read, to re-read,<lb/> to ponder,
                  to be proud of. Its author has at last won<lb/> the bâton of a Field-Marshal in
                  the army of contem-<lb/>porary novelists. Mr. <ref target="#ASW">Swinburne</ref>,
                  on the other hand,<lb/> has given a further and now serious impetus to the
                  <lb/>retrograde movement of his great reputation. He is <lb/>a poet of, at his
                  best, so rare and high a genius that <lb/>many readers, during perusal of <emph
                     rend="italic">The Sisters</emph>, will be<lb/> tempted to believe in the
                  Doppelganger legend. Who<lb/> is Mr. Swinburne's double? It is an undesirable
                  co-<lb/>partnery. The lesser man, who had already satisfied<lb/> us of his
                  inability to sustain the honour done him,<lb/> should now retire. Mr. Swinburne
                  has played double-<lb/>dummy with him long enough.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p>
                  <emph rend="indent"/><emph rend="italic">The Sisters</emph> is the production of a
                  tamed Elizabethan.<lb/> It has fine things that might almost be written by<lb/>
                  Webster, or at least by Cyril Tourneur, if one or other<lb/> of these dramatists
                  be thought of as a contemporary,<lb/> and maugre that special quality of spiritual
                  audacity<lb/> and intellectual bravura so characteristic of each, and<lb/> that
                  Mr. Swinburne himself at one time possessed. On <lb/>the other hand, it has pages
                  of drawing-room realism,<lb/> of "Friendship's-Offering" sentiment, of a dulness
                  un-<lb/>equalled by anything in "the new humour." It has<lb/> passages that would
                  make love impossible of continu-</p>


               <!--HEADER-->
               <pb n="63"/>
               <fw type="runningHead">
                  <fw type="pageNumLeft">60</fw>
                  <fw type="headRight">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160; &#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;
                     &#160;&#160; THE PAGAN
                     REVIEW</fw>
               </fw>
               <!--HEADER-->


               <p>ance: lovers can understand "speaking silence" but<lb/> not diction where
                  cherished commonplaces are choked<lb/> in struggling rhetoric. There are other
                  passages that<lb/> I recommend to the tender mercies of the University
                  <lb/>Extension-Lecturer. He can then lay horrid pitfalls<lb/> for the unwary, for
                  who among them will be able to<lb/> say if the given excerpts be execrable verse
                  or villainous<lb/> prose? There are lines, alas, which excruciate the ear:
                  <lb/>lines worthy of Byron at his worst, of a fibrelessness so <lb/>perverse, of
                  so maladroit a turn, that the ear of the<lb/> metricist revolts. And yet Mr.
                  Swinburne is a prince<lb/> of his craft in knowledge and skill! No: it is the<lb/>
                  mysterious double who hath done this thing. It is a <lb/>bitter thing to tell a
                  poet that we prefer his prose, but<lb/> even a recantatory essay on Byron or
                  Whitman—the two<lb/> magnificent derelict comets of modern poetry whose tails
                  <lb/>have been so carefully pulled by Mr. Swinburne while<lb/> under the
                  impression. that he was grappling with the <lb/>luminaries in front—would be
                  preferable to <emph rend="italic">The Sisters</emph>. <lb/>For no one need read
                  Mr. Swinburne the critic of modern<lb/> men, but everyone must read Mr. Swinburne
                  the poet.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>If <emph rend="italic">The Sisters</emph> be a poor play it
                  contains, besides<lb/> many beautiful passages, lyrical interludes of surpassing
                  <lb/>grace. To read the lyric "Love and Sorrow met in <lb/>May" is to rejoice that
                  we have a great poet still <lb/>among us. When this drama itself is known only
                  of<lb/> rust and the moth, the flawless lyric it enshrines shall<lb/> have put on
                  immortality as a garment.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>The half-year that is over has been further note-<lb/>worthy
                  for two new books by Mr. George Meredith: if, <lb/>indeed, the reprint of his
                     superb<emph rend="italic"> Modern Love</emph>, with<lb/> later additions, can
                  be called a new book. His novel,<lb/>
                  <emph rend="italic">One of Our Conquerors</emph>, has sown discord among the
                  <lb/>faithful. Enthusiasts call it manna: the cavillers will<lb/> have it that it
                  is a St. John's feast with a multiplicity <lb/>of hard locusts to a small benefice
                  of wild honey. One <lb/>can certainly discern in it George Meredith at his
                  best:<lb/> it is easier, however, to find him in his least winsome<lb/> aspect. He
                  is the electric light among contemporary<lb/> illuminators of our darkness.</p>

               <!--HEADER-->
               <pb n="64"/>

               <fw type="runningHead">
                  <fw type="headLeft">CONTEMPORARY RECORD</fw>
                  <fw type="pageNumRight">&#160;&#160; 61</fw>
               </fw>
               <!--HEADER-->

               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>

               <p><emph rend="indent"/>The Poet Laureate is what no other like dignitary<lb/> has
                  been: the most consummate poetic artist of his <lb/>time. He is Sovereign of the
                  Victorians. But he is not<lb/> a dramatist, though he can sometimes write
                  dramatically.<lb/> His <emph rend="italic">Foresters</emph> is a lovely pastoral,
                  with some happy<lb/> songs; but the England of Robin Hood is just what we <lb/>do
                  not find reflected in its exqusitely polished mirror.<lb/> This drama is even more
                  a Court-of-Victoria-fin-de-<lb/>siecle rendering of the wild life it nominally
                  represents<lb/> than the "Idyls of the King" are of the Arthurian past.<lb/> As a
                  stage play <emph rend="italic">The Foresters</emph> is eminently suited to<lb/>
                  please British and American audiences, having neither<lb/> intensity of vision,
                  overmastery of passion, vigour of dia-<lb/>logue, nor convincing
                  verisimilitude.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>Lord Lytton, who lisped in his father's fiction, died a<lb/>
                  writer of verse. He was a worthy private citizen; as a<lb/> public man, an
                  ornamental Imperialist; as a diplomatist,<lb/> a sign-post to warn new-comers to
                  take the other way.<lb/> He was saved from being a bad Oriental by being an<lb/>
                  unconventional Occidental.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>As a poet, he was . . . . . . a worthy son of his father.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>A greater than many Lyttons passed away in <lb/>the person of
                  Walt Whitman. This great pioneer of a<lb/> new literature has so many faults in
                  the view of<lb/> most of his contemporaries that they cannot discern the
                  volcano<lb/> beneath the scoriæ. Let us defy mixt metaphors, and<lb/> add that we
                  believe those who come after us will<lb/> look upon him as the Janitor of the New
                  House Beautiful.<lb/> Meanwhile all Whitmaniacs (the courteous appellation<lb/> is
                  not ours) must rejoice in the convincing, if unconscious,<lb/> tribute paid with
                  so much delicacy and graciousness<lb/> by the writer of a certain famous <emph
                     rend="italic">Athenœum </emph>critique. </p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>Mr. Hall Caine has written <emph rend="italic">The
                     Scapegoat</emph>. He has also<lb/> re-written it. The experiment reflects
                  credit on him as a<lb/> conscientious workman, but is in other respects an
                  awful<lb/> example to set to the young. Horrible possibilities are<lb/> suggested.
                  Burke and Hare will be outdone in the resur-<lb/>recting business. Mudie will have
                  to start duplicate shelves,</p>

               <!--HEADER-->
               <pb n="65"/>
               <fw type="runningHead">
                  <fw type="pageNumLeft">62</fw>
                  <fw type="headRight">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160; &#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;
                     &#160;&#160; THE PAGAN REVIEW</fw>
               </fw>
               <!--HEADER-->

               <p>the upper marked <emph rend="italic">As they Were</emph>, the lower <emph
                     rend="italic">As they Are</emph>.<lb/> The dead will arise and walk in a new
                  ghastliness.</p>

               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>

               <p><emph rend="indent"/>
                  <emph rend="italic">The Naulahka</emph> proves that two clever men can
                  legally<lb/> procure an abortion.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>Mr. Mallock's <emph rend="italic">Human Document</emph>
                  should be filed at<lb/> once. It can then be put away.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>In Robert Louis Stevenson's new books, <emph rend="italic"
                  >Across the<lb/> Plains</emph> and <emph rend="italic">The Wrecker</emph>,
                  there are wells of pure delight.<lb/> The sunshine of genius is in both, though
                  the former is<lb/> but a series of collected papers and the latter a romance<lb/>
                  of adventure. The delight of these books cancels the<lb/> deep disappointment of
                  the "South-Sea Letters." There<lb/> are pages of "The Lantern-Bearers" and
                  "Fontaine-<lb/>bleau" which ought to be committed to memory by<lb/> every aspirant
                  in the literary life.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5a">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>The novel of the year, in France—a year given over<lb/> to
                  strange aberrations from the well-defined "stream of<lb/> tendency" of the French
                  mind, from a lurid colour-study<lb/> by the Flemish-Parisian Huysmans to the
                  serene cold-<lb/>bloodedness of Maurice Barrès, or the scientific romancing<lb/>
                  of J. H. Rosny—is Zola's recently published <emph rend="italic">La
                  Débâcle</emph>.<lb/> It should be read not only as perhaps the most mature<lb/>
                  and splendid effort of a great writer—a great writer who<lb/> has reached the
                  Temple of Fame through seas of mud,<lb/> and, unfortunately, has brought a good
                  deal with him,<lb/> even to the white steps of the portico; but also as a
                  work<lb/> likely to have a remarkable effect on the political temper<lb/> and
                  ideals of the French people. <emph rend="italic">La Débâcle</emph> may prove<lb/>
                  to be a factor of supreme international significance, in<lb/> the relations of
                  France and Germany. In this country,<lb/> even, it will attract almost as much
                  attention as the<lb/> marriage of a duke or the misdemeanour of an actress.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5b">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>Maurice Maeterlinck—who stabbed himself with a bod-<lb/>kin
                  in <emph rend="italic">Les Sept Princesses</emph>—has, in <emph rend="italic"
                     >Pelle-as et Melisande</emph>,<lb/> opened a vein. There is just a chance it is
                  not an artery.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent5b">&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#160;&#8258;</emph></p>
               <p><emph rend="indent"/>Next month a word to <emph rend="italic">les jeunes</emph>
                  here.</p>
               <p><emph rend="indent6"/>
                  <ref target="#WSH">W. H. B.</ref>
               </p>
            </div>
         </div>
      </body>
   </text>
</TEI>
