<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<?xml-model href="../../../Schema,%20CSS%20and%20Template%20Files/YB_schema2.rnc" type="application/relax-ng-compact-syntax"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
    <teiHeader>
        <fileDesc>
            <titleStmt>
                <title>The Yellow Nineties Online</title>
                <title>The Spectator, 22 February 1896</title>
                <title type="EG1_Review_Nature_1895"/>
                <editor>Lorraine Janzen Kooistra</editor>
            </titleStmt>
            <editionStmt>
                <edition>
                    <date>2019</date>
                </edition>
            </editionStmt>
            <publicationStmt>
                <idno>R_TS_0296_EGV2_PAGEANT1</idno>
                
                <publisher>The Yellow Nineties Online</publisher>
                <pubPlace>Ryerson University</pubPlace>
                <address>
                    <addrLine>English Department</addrLine>
                    <addrLine>350 Victoria Street,</addrLine>
                    <addrLine>Toronto ON,</addrLine>
                    <addrLine>M5B 2K3</addrLine>
                    <addrLine>Canada</addrLine>
                </address>
                <availability>
                    <p>Usable according to the Creative Commons License <ref
                        target="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/">Attribution
                        Non-commercial Share-alike</ref>.</p>
                </availability>
            </publicationStmt>
            <sourceDesc>
                <biblStruct>
                    <monogr>
                        <editor>Unknown</editor>
                        <author>Unknown</author>
                        <title level="j">The Spectator</title>
                        <title level="a"><emph rend="italic">&#8220;THE PAGEANT,&#8221; AND TWO OTHER MISCELLANIES.</emph></title>
                        <imprint>
                            <publisher>Unknown</publisher>
                            <pubPlace>Unknown</pubPlace>
                            <date>29 Aug 1895</date>
                            <biblScope>"'THE PAGEANT,' AND TWO OTHER MISCELLANIES." Review of <emph rend="italic">The Evergreen: A Northern Seasonal</emph>,
                                vol.2, Autumn 1985, and <emph rend="italic">The Pageant</emph>, 1896, <emph rend="italic">The Spectator</emph>, 29 Aug 1895, pp. 274. <emph rend="italic">Yellow
                                        Nineties 2.0,</emph> edited by Lorraine Janzen Kooistra,
                                Ryerson University Centre for Digital Humanities, 2019.
                                https://1890s.ca/EG2_Pagent1_Review_TheSpectator_Feb1896/
                            </biblScope>
                        </imprint>
                    </monogr>
                </biblStruct>
            </sourceDesc>
        </fileDesc>
        <encodingDesc>
            <editorialDecl>
                <p>Our editorial method is informed by social-text editing principles. By “text” we mean
                    verbal and visual printed material, including non-referential physical elements such as
                    bindings, page layouts, and ornaments. We view any text as the outcome of collaborative
                    processes that have specific manifestations at precise historical moments.
                    The Yellow Nineties Online publishes facsimile editions of a select collection of fin-de-
                    siècle aesthetic periodicals, together with paratexts of production and reception such as
                    cover designs, advertising materials, and reviews. This historical material is enhanced
                    by two kinds of peer-reviewed scholarly commentary: biographies of the periodicals’
                    contributors and associates; and critical introductions to each title and volume by
                    experts in the field. All scholarly material on the site is vetted by the editor(s) and peer-
                    reviewed by them and/or an international board of advisors. The site as a whole is peer-
                    reviewed by NINES (Networked Infrastructure for Nineteenth-Century Electronic
                    Scholarship). Contributors to the site retain personal copyright in their material. The
                    site is licensed with a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0
                    license. Both primary and secondary materials, including all visual images, are marked
                    up in TEI- (Textual-Encoding Initiative) compliant XML (Extensible Markup
                    Language). To ensure maximum flexibility for users, magazines are available on the site
                    as virtual objects (facsimiles) in FlipBook form; in HTML for online reading; in PDF for
                    downloading and collecting; and in XML for those who wish to review and/or adapt our
                    tag sets. In order to make ornamental devices, such as initial letters, head- and tail-
                    pieces, searchable, we have developed a Database of Ornament in OMEKA, and linked it
                    to the relevant pages of each magazine edition. As a dynamic structure, a scholarly
                    website is always in process; Phase One of The Yellow Nineties Online (2010-2015) is
                    completed and Phase Two (2016-2021) is underway.</p>
            </editorialDecl>
        </encodingDesc>
        <profileDesc>
            <creation>
                <date>1895</date>
            </creation>
            <langUsage>
                <language ident="en">English</language>
            </langUsage>
            <textClass>
                <keywords scheme="#lcsh">
                    <list>
                        <item>English literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals</item>
                        <item>Great Britain -- Periodicals</item>
                    </list>
                </keywords>
                <keywords scheme="ninesGenre">
                    <list>
                        <item>Review</item>
                        <note>Possible Genres (multiple): "Fiction," "Nonfiction," "Poetry," "Paratext" (TOC, prospecti, advertisements, frontmatter, titlepage), "Review" (older reviews),
                            "Criticism" (including critical introductions), "Visual Art" (images, bio images), Historiography (bios),"Bibliography"
                            (intros, crit, bios, anything with a bibliography attached), "Drama," "Ephemera," "Translation," "Religion," 
                            "Travel Writing," "Music, Other,")
                            <!--Add items as necessary. Remove items not used.-->
                        </note>
                    </list>
                </keywords>
                
                <keywords scheme="ninesType">
                    <list>
                        <item>Periodical</item>
                        <note>Possible Types (singular): "Periodical" (texts/most stuff), "Interactive Resource" (current writing, 
                            biographies, not old reviews), "Still Image" (images, visual art), "Physical Object" (posters,
                            prospecti)</note>
                        <!-- only choose one item-->
                    </list>
                </keywords>
                
                <keywords scheme="ninesDiscipline">
                    <list>
                        <item>Book History</item>
                        <item>literature</item>
                        <note>Possible Disciplines (multiple): "Book History (include for all periodical items)," "Literature," "Art History (use for art, also use for reviews)," "History (don't use in a general sense)," "Theatre Studies,"
                            "Musicology," "Philosophy," "Anthropology," "Science"</note>
                        <!--Add items as necessary. Remove items not used.-->
                    </list>
                </keywords>
            </textClass>
        </profileDesc>
    </teiHeader>
    <text>
        <body>
            
            <head>
                <title level="a"><emph rend="italic">&#8220;THE PAGEANT,&#8221; AND TWO OTHER MISCELLANIES.</emph></title>
            </head>
            <p> 
                <emph rend="italic">The Pageant</emph> is a rightly conceived mixture of literature and <lb/>
                graphic art.&#160; Instead of illustrations furnished by some <lb/>
                indifferent hack to story or essay, and wordy description <lb/>
                written round pictures, we have here drawings, verses, prose, <lb/>
                appealing each on their own merits. The exceptions are of <lb/>
                the kind that justify themselves.&#160; <ref target="#PVE">Verlaine</ref>'s reverie upon <lb/>
                Rossetti's <emph rend="italic">Monna Rosa</emph> is called forth by a real personal <lb/>
                sympathy, and the same attraction to·a kindred spirit in<lb/>
                another art is evinced by Mr. Ricketts's illustrative work, as<lb/>
                it was by Rossetti in his drawings for Tennyson.<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent"></emph>We may take the graphic art first, for the newer contribu-<lb/>
                tors on this side are stronger than the writers.&#160; It is needless<lb/>
                to speak of the admirable work by acknowledged masters,<lb/>
                Rossetti, Watts, Whistler, Millais, Burne-Jones.&#160; The newer<lb/>
                men do no discredit to this company.&#160; The leading spirits are<lb/>
                Messrs. <ref target="#CRI">Ricketts</ref> and <ref target="#CSH">Shannon</ref>.&#160; The <emph rend="italic">Oedipus</emph> of the first<lb/>
                displays the remarkable blending in its author of classical<lb/>
                taste and knowledge with a delight in romantic intricacy and<lb/>
                suggestion.&#160; In the <emph rend="italic">Psyche</emph> the balance has turned perhaps<lb/>
                a little too far in the direction of pattern lines, instead of<lb/>
                expressive lines ; but it is the work of the only possible pre-<lb/>
                tender in the younger generation to the heritage of tbe<lb/>
                Rossetti of 1857.&#160; Of Mr. Shannon's two drawings, one suffers<lb/>
                in reproduction ; but both prove, like all his work, a spirit of<lb/>
                real imaginative delicacy.&#160; The same is true of <ref target="#CCO">Mr. Charles</ref><lb/>
                <ref target="#CCO">Conder</ref>'s &#8220;Blue Bird&#8221; of good luck, flitting above a company<lb/>
                of gallants and ladies in a garden.&#160; Mr. Reginald Savage and<lb/>
                Mr. <ref target="#LHA">Laurence Housman</ref>, if we cannot at present put them on<lb/>
                so bigh a level, have a distinct talent ; the former expresses<lb/>
                himself something in the fashion of Madox Brown, the latter<lb/>
                has a turn for grotesque design and amazing minuteness of<lb/>
                execution.&#160; Mr. <ref target="#WRO">Rothenstein</ref>'s lithograph of Mr. <ref target="#ASW">Swinburne</ref><lb/>
                is strongly characterised in the head.<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent"></emph>The literature includes a lovely variant by Maeterlinck on<lb/>
                one of Ophelia's songs, beginning:&#x2014;<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent4"></emph>&#160;&#8220;'Et s'il revenait un jour<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent4"></emph>&#160;Que faut-il lui dire?<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent4"></emph>&#160;'Dites-lui qu'on l'attendit<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent4"></emph>&#160;Jusqu'&#224; s'en mourir.'&#8221;<lb/>
                The dramatic piece, <emph rend="italic">Tintagiles</emph>, reveals too much of the<lb/>
                author's machinery of images for thrills.&#160; It is not to<lb/>
                be reckoned with <emph rend="italic">L'Intrus</emph>.&#160; A like overemphasis of the<lb/>
                machinery of phrase hurts Mr. Swinburne's sunset picture of<lb/>
                "Theleme."&#160; A tender lyric by Mr. Henley, and two poems<lb/>
                by Mr. Robert Bridges, are the only other remarkable verses.<lb/>
                Of less-known writers, the most interesting is Mr. <ref target="#JGR">John</ref><lb/>
                <ref target="#JGR">Gray</ref>.&#160; A criticism by Mr. York Powell, in which something,<lb/>
                for a wonder, is said on the author of <emph rend="italic">Sidonia</emph>, and a glimpse<lb/>
                into the imaginative history of the Moors, by Mr. <ref target="#GGR">Cunning</ref>-<lb/>
                <ref target="#GGR">hame Graham</ref>, appeal to us most among the remaining pieces.<lb/>
                It is a pleasure to find a book put together with so much<lb/>
                taste in the choice of its contents, the arrangement of its<lb/>
                type, and the design of·its cover.&#160; A miscellany like this at<lb/>
                six shillings is cheap indeed.<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent"></emph><emph rend="italic">A London Garland</emph> is a collection of illustrations by members<lb/>
                of the Illustrators' Society, upon occasion furnished by Mr.<lb/>
                Henley's selection of poems dealing with London.&#160; The<lb/>
                Society of Illustrators is a body formed with the excellent<lb/>
                idea of guarding the commercial interests of the members<lb/>
                against the rapacity of publishers and editors of the baser<lb/>
                sort, or their own ignorance and carelessness.&#160; In fact, it is<lb/>
                intended to do for the illustrator what the Authors' Society<lb/>
                has taken in hand for the writer.&#160; Such a body is not of<lb/>
                course formed on an artistic but on a professional basis, and<lb/>
                must include men of all degrees of merit.&#160; It is therefore ill-<lb/>
                framed to carry out consistently an artistic project, and a<lb/>
                miscellany of contributions from its members must exhibit<lb/>
                too great an inequality, as well as too great a variety of<lb/>
                styles, to make it possible to admire the book as a whole.<lb/>
                The work, in fact, ranges down to some striking examples of<lb/>
                inaptness and wash-drawing of the common type.&#160; But on<lb/>
                the other hand, besides pictures or drawings of repute not<lb/>
                executed expressly for the book, there are several good<lb/>
                numbers among the illustrations; we may name, in parti-<lb/>
                cular, the drawings of Messrs. Abbey, <ref target="#ARU">W. W. Russell</ref>, Edgar<lb/>
                Wilson, A. S. Hartrick, H. Tonks, Raven Hill, W. Hatherell,<lb/>
                Paul Renouard, <ref target="#ABE">Aubrey Beardsley</ref>, and the <emph rend="italic">Fog</emph> of Mr.<lb/>
                <ref target="#JPE">Pennell</ref>.&#160; The book, indeed, is a fair epitome of the run of<lb/>
                illustration of the day,&#x2014;good, middling, and bad.<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent"></emph>Mr. Henley bas made the best of a difficult business in<lb/>
                selecting the poems, for to take &#8220;London&#8221; as the peg for an<lb/>
                anthology is to proceed on a very accidental principle.&#160; Mr.<lb/>
                Henley's own poems are among the few centrally inspired by<lb/>
                the idea of London.&#160; Wordsworth's sonnet is another case;<lb/>
                Mr. <ref target="#JWH">Whistler</ref>'s <emph rend="italic">Nocturne</emph> a third.&#160; It is with an uncomfortable<lb/>
                jerk that we attempt to bring London to the front in reading<lb/>
                many of these poems.&#160; The prose of Charles Lamb, De Quincey,<lb/>
                and others strikes the more conscious attitude required.&#160; But<lb/>
                we need not take Mr. Henley's part in the project more gravely<lb/>
                than he does him5elf.&#160; The main idea, after all, was to furnish<lb/>
                pretexts for illustrations, and for some superstitious reason the<lb/>
                makers of books are still loath to say to their draughtsman,<lb/>
                'Go and make London drawings without troubling to find a<lb/>
                warrant in a poem.' A word must be said for the well-designed<lb/>
                end-papers by Mr. <ref target="#GWH">Gleeson White</ref>.<lb/>
                <emph rend="indent"></emph>For the good intentions and some of the ideas of the pro-<lb/>
                ducers of <emph rend="italic">The Evergreen</emph> we have sympathy ; but they appear<lb/>
                to us to confuse the ardent desire for the presence of art with<lb/>
                the power to produce it.&#160; The essence of their movement for a<lb/>
                &#8220;Scots Renascence&#8221; would appear to be a kind of social settle-<lb/>
                ment including University teachers and students, and they are<lb/>
                anxious to add culture and an artistic creation to their study<lb/>
                of science and aspiration after social good-fellowship.&#160; But<lb/>
                these things do not come only by wishing and taking thought<lb/>
                and trying.&#160; Talent too is nooessary, and is not to be had to<lb/>
                order.&#160; These two numbers of the &#8220;Seasonal&#8221; are marked<lb/>
                by an anxious self-consciousness, an effort to have style that<lb/>
                defeats itself.&#160; The type has so much of this style that it is<lb/>
                ugly and unreadable.&#160; Style stands like a grille before the<lb/>
                articles, and hits one in the eye from the drawings. We find,<lb/>
                however, some feeling and talent in the writing of Miss <ref target="#WSH">Fiona</ref><lb/>
                <ref target="#WSH">MacLeod</ref>, and in Mr. <ref target="#CMAC">Charles Mackie</ref>'s <emph rend="italic">Hide and Seek</emph>.<lb/>
            </p>
        </body>
    </text>
</TEI>


